HomeLegal Hallucinations Database
Ripplemesh OIRipplemesh

Resources · Legal Hallucinations Database

When AI Makes Up the Law — Court Decisions Tracked

A live database of court decisions where generative AI produced hallucinated content — fake citations, false quotes, and misrepresented authority — refreshed twice a week.

2,293

court decisions identified so far

14 November 2026

Source last updated

Nov 16, 2026

Last checked by Ripplemesh (Mon & Thu)

About the database

What is tracked

The database tracks legal decisions — documents where a court or tribunal addresses AI use in more than a passing reference — in which generative AI produced hallucinated content, typically fake citations but also other AI-generated arguments. It covers cases where the court found (or implied) that a party relied on hallucinated material, plus a small number where AI use was alleged but not confirmed.

It does not track the wider universe of all fake citations or all AI use in court filings. It is a work in progress and expands as new examples emerge.

Trends & metrics

The Data at a Glance

Cases over time (by decision date)

Q2 2023Q4 2023Q2 2024Q4 2024Q2 2025Q4 2025Q2 2026Q4 202601503004506000600120018002400
  • Per quarter
  • Cumulative

n = 2293 decisions

Timing: offending document vs. decision

Q2 2023Q4 2023Q2 2024Q4 2024Q2 2025Q4 2025Q2 2026Q4 2026060120180240
  • Decision date
  • Offending document date

n = 1102 cases with both dates known (1187 without a stated document date, 4 unparseable).

Who used AI, over time

Q2 2023Q4 2023Q2 2024Q4 2024Q2 2025Q4 2025Q2 2026Q4 20260%30%60%100.1%
  • Lawyer
  • Pro se
  • Other

n = 2282 cases with a known party. Shares are of cases per quarter.

By jurisdiction

040080012001600USACanadaAustraliaUKIsraelBrazilIndiaItalyFranceGermanyArgentinaPolandOther

n = 2295 (counted once per state) · 1 untagged

Top 20 U.S. states

04080120160CaliforniaNew YorkTexasFloridaIllinoisMichiganArizonaPennsylvaniaWashingtonIndianaNevadaOhioColoradoMarylandOregonNew JerseyMinnesotaOklahomaMissouriGeorgia

U.S. cases by state, parsed from the court field.

Nature of hallucination

  • Fabricated
  • Misrepresented
  • False Quotes
  • Outdated Advice

n = 6794 items across 2172 cases · 121 cases without items

Nature – subcategory

01500300045006000Case LawLegal NormExhibits &SubmissionsDoctrinal WorkOtherOverturned CaseLawRepealed Law

n = 6794 items

Outcome severity

Monetary sanctionDisciplinary referral0100200300400

n = 2267 cases (excludes 26 alleged-only)

Monetary penalty distribution (USD)

0–100100–1k1k–5k5k–10k10k–50k50k+0255075100

n = 200 USD penalties · 129 in other currencies (not shown) · 68 with an unknown amount (excluded)

By legal field

0150300450600ContractAdministrativeCivil rightsEmploymentTortOtherFamilyCriminalBankruptcyImmigrationTaxIPLandlord-tenantHabeas

n = 1991 cases · 302 with no legal field recorded

Offending document by month of year

JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec03570105140

n = 1102 documents with a parsed date (month of filing, all years combined)

AI tools named

04080120160ChatGPT / OpenAIGoogle Gemini /BardClaudeWestlaw /CoCounselMicrosoft CopilotLexisNexisPerplexityFastcase / vLexGrokGrammarlyDeepSeekOther

n = 245 cases named a specific tool · 2048 logged as “Implied” / “Unidentified” (excluded).

Excuses & responses when caught

0150300450600Attempt towithdraw/Correctthe filingApologiesOtherDenyingBlaming: A toolBlaming: OtherSetting upsystems in lawfirmBlaming: A juniorSpontaneous CLEDoubling downRefusing toanswerSpontaneouscosts repaymentBlaming: TheclientBlaming: Aco-counsel

n = 828 cases · 1465 where the response was not addressed. Extracted automatically and simplified into set categories.

Case register

Search Cases

2,316 matching cases

CaseCourt / JurisdictionDateParty Using AIAI ToolNature of HallucinationOutcome / SanctionPenalty
Orlando Chechitelli v. Etiwanda School District, et al. C.D. California
USA
Nov 26, 2026LawyerImpliedFabricated: Legal Norm (1); Fabricated: Doctrinal Work (1)Bar Referral
Disciplinary referral
—
עטיה דויך נ' מתקני פסגות בע"מ Tel Aviv Regional Labor Court
Israel
Nov 8, 2026LawyerImpliedFabricated: Case Law (7); False Quotes: Case Law (1)——
Salgado v. Fred Palla Farms, Inc. CA California (5d)
USA
Nov 6, 2026LawyerImpliedFabricated: Case Law (1)Monetary Sanction; Bar Referral
Disciplinary referral
5,000
State v. Pryor CA Tennessee
USA
Nov 5, 2026LawyerImpliedFabricated: Case Law (2)Warning—
In re the Marriage of Murad AllegedCA California (4d)
USA
Nov 5, 2026Pro Se LitigantImpliedFabricated: Case Law (1)——
Stevenson v. Schultz (consolidated with Schultz v. Stevenson) CA California (3d)
USA
Nov 4, 2026Pro Se LitigantImpliedFabricated: Case Law (2); Misrepresented: Case Law (1)Admonishment—
Liu v. Rubio D. D.C.
USA
Nov 4, 2026Pro Se LitigantImpliedFabricated: Case Law (1)——
United States v. Khalwinder Singh Bhengura N.D. Texas
USA
Nov 4, 2026LawyerChatGPTMisrepresented: Case Law (2)Warning—
Donovan Lamonte Haley v. Kim Rutledge, et al. C.D. California
USA
Nov 4, 2026Pro Se LitigantGoogle AIMisrepresented: Legal Norm (1); Misrepresented: Case Law (1)Warning—
McCann-Cross v. Coras Wellness and Behavioral Health D. Delaware
USA
Nov 3, 2026Pro Se LitigantImpliedFabricated: Case Law (3)——
Vokshi v Canada (Citizenship and Immigration) Federal Court of Canada
Canada
Nov 3, 2026Pro Se LitigantImpliedFabricated: Case Law (1)——
Mapp v Vasyukevich SC New York
USA
Nov 2, 2026Pro Se LitigantImpliedFabricated: Case Law (3)——
Larkin v. Menard, Inc., et al. CA Minnesota
USA
Nov 2, 2026Pro Se LitigantImpliedFabricated: Case Law (1)——
Sturghiss v. Staggers S.D. Indiana
USA
Nov 2, 2026LawyerImpliedMisrepresented: Case Law (3); False Quotes: Case Law (1)Order to Show Cause—
Safe Homes Saint Paul v. City of St. Paul CA Minnesota
USA
Nov 2, 2026LawyerUnidentifiedMisrepresented: Case Law (1); False Quotes: Case Law (1)——
Taieb v. Universal Music Publishing, Inc. D. Nevada
USA
Nov 2, 2026Pro Se LitigantImpliedFalse Quotes: Case Law (2); Fabricated: Case Law (1)Warning—
Nejadi c. Tribunal administratif du logement Quebec SC
Canada
Oct 30, 2026Pro Se LitigantImpliedFabricated: Case Law (1)Monetary Sanction1,000
Quanta Logistics Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs (Import-I) & Anr. Bombay High Court
India
Oct 30, 2026JudgeImpliedFabricated: Case Law (1)Customs order quashed—
In the Estate of John Raburn Ford, Deceased CA Texas
USA
Oct 29, 2026LawyerImplied———
The King v Director of Public Prosecutions High Court of Justice
UK
Oct 29, 2026LawyerImpliedFabricated: Case Law (1)——
Developed by Design, LLC v. James M. Travis et al. CA Tennessee
USA
Oct 29, 2026LawyerImpliedFabricated: Case Law (1); False Quotes: Case Law (1)——
Nabors v. Nabors CA Indiana
USA
Oct 29, 2026Pro Se LitigantImpliedFabricated: Case Law (1)Admonishment—
Timothy Lashbrook v Estate of Ila Grasak CA Michigan
USA
Oct 28, 2026LawyerImpliedMisrepresented: Case Law (3)Order to Show Cause—
2028604 Ontario Ltd. v. His Majesty the King Tax Court of Canada
Canada
Oct 28, 2026LawyerUnidentifiedMisrepresented: Case Law (1); Fabricated: Case Law (1)Warning—
PC-59 Doe v Jewish Bd. of Family & Children's Servs., Inc. SC New York
USA
Oct 28, 2026LawyerUnidentifiedFalse Quotes: Case Law (1); Misrepresented: Exhibits & Submissions (1); Misrepresented: Legal Norm (1); Misrepresented: Case Law (1)Monetary Sanction250

Data source & attribution

All case data and chart statistics on this page come from the AI Hallucination Cases Database created and maintained by Damien Charlotin, licensed under CC BY 4.0. Ripplemesh refreshes its copy twice a week and presents it in its own visual style; it is not affiliated with or endorsed by the source. Source last updated: 14 November 2026.

Cite as: AI Hallucination Cases Database, Damien Charlotin, https://www.damiencharlotin.com/hallucinations/. Have a case to add? Contact the database author via the source site.

We don't use third-party advertising or tracking cookies. We use essential cookies to keep you signed in and basic analytics to understand site usage, and we collect personal information only when you submit a form (like contact or demo requests). See our Privacy Policy for details.